Active or passive defense?

Card play problem · Level Advanced · Set by Thibaud Vincenot

Sud joue 3♥, vous défendez en Est. Personne n'est vulnérable. Vous êtes au pli n°2.

Dealer
South
Vulnerability
Nobody
Contract
3♥ played by South

Your hand (East)

  • ♠ K 9 7
  • ♥ J 6
  • ♦ K J 8 2
  • ♣ K 10 7 4

The other visible hand (North)

  • ♠ 10 6 4 2
  • ♥ K 10 4 3
  • ♦ A 9
  • ♣ J 6 3

The auction

  1. South: 1NT
  2. West: Pass
  3. North: 2♣
  4. East: Pass
  5. South: 2♥
  6. West: Pass
  7. North: 3♥
  8. East: Pass
  9. South: Pass
  10. West: Pass

The question

What should you return?

Play this problem on Bridge It!

The teacher’s solution

Dummy is flat. There is little chance that an active defense is called for: so return a diamond passively.

Given the ♠10 in dummy, returning a spade would not be entirely neutral. In that case, declarer would concede only one trick in the suit. A club switch is also to be set aside, because it would mean handling the suit for the opponents.

By going on playing neutrally for the rest of the deal, we should make two spades, two clubs and one diamond.