Defense: reading the opening lead correctly

Card play problem · Level Advanced · Set by Thibaud Vincenot

Sud joue 4♠, vous défendez en Est, personne n'est vulnérable. Ouest entame du 9 de Cœur.

Dealer
South
Vulnerability
Nobody
Contract
4♠ played by South

Your hand (East)

  • ♠ 3 2
  • ♥ A 6 5 4
  • ♦ 5 4 3 2
  • ♣ J 3 2

The other visible hand (North)

  • ♠ Q 10 8 7
  • ♥ K Q J 2
  • ♦ Q 6
  • ♣ 10 5 4

The auction

  1. South: 1NT
  2. West: Pass
  3. North: 2♣
  4. East: Pass
  5. South: 2♠
  6. West: Pass
  7. North: 4♠
  8. East: Pass
  9. South: Pass
  10. West: Pass

The question

How do you see the rest of the play? What should you follow suit with?

Play this problem on Bridge It!

The teacher’s solution

The opening lead of the 9 shows either a singleton or a doubleton. In this case, the 9 can't be a singleton, because that would mean South has four hearts, whereas with 4 hearts and 4 spades, they would have responded 2NT to the Stayman. This means West is doubleton in hearts.

If we want to keep communications open with partner's hand, we absolutely must not win the ♥A right away. When partner regains the lead a little later, they'll be able to return a heart to us, and we'll be able to give them a ruff.