Defense: reading partner's card played

Card play problem · Level Intermediate · Set by Thibaud Vincenot

South plays 3NT, you defend as West, nobody is vulnerable. You are in hand on the second trick.

Dealer
North
Vulnerability
Nobody
Contract
3NT played by South

Your hand (West)

  • ♠ 9 8 5 3
  • ♥ 8 3
  • ♦ Q 8
  • ♣ A K J 9 7

The other visible hand (North)

  • ♠ J 2
  • ♥ A K 7
  • ♦ A K J 10 9 7
  • ♣ 6 5

The auction

  1. North: 1♦
  2. East: Pass
  3. South: 1♥
  4. West: Pass
  5. North: 3♦
  6. East: Pass
  7. South: 3NT
  8. West: Pass
  9. North: Pass
  10. East: Pass

The question

What should be returned?

Play this problem on Bridge It!

The teacher’s solution

By playing the 2 of clubs, partner tells us both that he does not have the ♣Q, because otherwise he would have unblocked it under the ♣K at the opening lead, and also that we can credit him with 3 cards in the suit. Indeed, when unblocking is not possible, one must show parity to partner. Thanks to this information, we can work out that South has the ♣Q third. We will therefore stop playing that suit to avoid establishing his Queen. The right return will be a spade. We hope that partner will win the trick with the ace to play clubs again so that we can capture South's Queen. Play back the ♠9 to show your lack of interest in spades.