Finding the right return
Card play problem · Level Expert · Set by Thibaud Vincenot
South plays 4♠, you defend as East, nobody is vulnerable. You are in hand on the second trick.
- Dealer
- South
- Vulnerability
- Nobody
- Contract
- 4♠ played by South
Your hand (East)
- ♠ 3 2
- ♥
A7 6 5 - ♦ 5 4 3 2
- ♣ A K 3
The other visible hand (North)
- ♠ K J 7
- ♥ 4
2 - ♦ A K Q 10 9
- ♣ 5 4 2
The auction
- South: 1♠
- West: Pass
- North: 2♦
- East: Pass
- South: 2♠
- West: Pass
- North: 4♠
- East: Pass
- South: Pass
- West: Pass
The question
What should you play next?
Play this problem on Bridge It!
The teacher’s solution
To defeat 4♠, you need to find 4 tricks. It's fairly easy to see how to find 3 tricks, but the last one is tricky to spot, knowing that partner has at most 1 high-card point outside hearts. You'll need to be both cunning and hope for a miracle. Since the only suit where you can make 3 tricks is clubs, you need to hope partner holds an honour. If he has the Q (unlikely), you can play back whichever club card you like. However, if he has the J, you must avoid playing the A/K, otherwise you'll establish the opponents' Q. Let's play back a small club: this will put declarer in a position to misplay the suit, for example if he holds Qxx in clubs. If by chance he plays the 10, partner will play his J and you'll take the A and K.