Defense: encouraging and discouraging signals

Card play problem · Level Expert · Set by Thibaud Vincenot

South plays 3NT, you defend as East, nobody is vulnerable. West leads the Ace of Hearts.

Dealer
South
Vulnerability
Nobody
Contract
3NT played by South

Your hand (East)

  • ♠ K J 10 6 5
  • ♥ Q 8 4 3
  • ♦ 3 2
  • ♣ 3 2

The other visible hand (North)

  • ♠ Q 7
  • ♥ 10 2
  • ♦ Q J 9 8 7
  • ♣ K J 10 6

The auction

  1. South: 1NT
  2. West: Pass
  3. North: 3NT
  4. East: Pass
  5. South: Pass
  6. West: Pass

The question

Which card should you play?

Play this problem on Bridge It!

The teacher’s solution

On the opening lead of the Ace at NT, we either encourage or discourage. It's very tempting to encourage with our hand since we hold the ♥Q. However, on one hand, a return in another suit would be preferable, and on the other hand, by persisting in hearts, we might establish a possible long Jack for the opponents. Let's discourage the lead by playing the ♥3 (our smallest card) and hope that partner returns spades.