Responses to the overcall at the 1 level

Bidding problem · Level Intermediate · Set by Thibaud Vincenot

You are sitting South, nobody is vulnerable and West is the dealer. West opens 1 diamond, North bids 1 heart, East passes.

Dealer
West
Vulnerability
Nobody

Your hand (South)

  • ♠ Q 6 5
  • ♥ K J 7 3
  • ♦ Q 7 2
  • ♣ J 8 3

The auction

  1. West: 1♦
  2. North: 1♥
  3. East: Pass

The question

What bid should you make?

Play this problem on Bridge It!

The teacher’s solution

A nine-card fit but no extra value! So it isn't reasonable to go to the 3 level with such a balanced hand. Don't forget that to make use of trumps, you need to be able to ruff. So let's just settle for 2♥. For now we have no hope of playing game, and bidding 3♥ would suggest an unbalanced hand.