Defense: finding the right return

Card play problem · Level Intermediate · Set by Thibaud Vincenot

South plays 4♥, you defend as East, everyone is vulnerable. You are in hand on the second trick.

Dealer
South
Vulnerability
All
Contract
4♥ played by South

Your hand (East)

  • ♠ A J 7 6 5
  • ♥ 9
  • ♦ 10 9 8 4 3
  • ♣ K 3

The other visible hand (North)

  • ♠ K Q 4 3
  • ♥ A 8 5
  • ♦ A 6 2
  • ♣ 7 6 2

The auction

  1. South: 3♥
  2. West: Pass
  3. North: 4♥
  4. East: Pass
  5. South: Pass
  6. West: Pass

The question

What should you play back?

Play this problem on Bridge It!

The teacher’s solution

Dummy is loaded with honours in every suit except clubs! Partner must have a little something in that suit given that opener has a weak hand based on hearts. Let's play back in dummy's weak suit using even-odd: the ♣K. If we had played back anything else, the opponents would have had time to discard a losing club on the ♠Q.